Sign in
RC

RLI CORP (RLI)·Q1 2025 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Q1 2025 delivered strong underwriting profitability (combined ratio 82.3%) with underwriting income of $70.5M, while GAAP net EPS fell to $0.68 due to $42.3M of unrealized equity losses; operating EPS was $0.92 .
  • EPS beat normalized/operating consensus, but consolidated revenue missed Street estimates as equity market marks reduced GAAP revenue; management highlighted investment income up 12% and comprehensive EPS of $1.01 . EPS Normalized consensus: $0.85* vs actual $0.92 (beat); Revenue consensus: $0.442B* vs actual $0.408B (miss). Values retrieved from S&P Global.
  • Segment strength: Property (57.1% combined) and Surety (68.5%) offset Casualty (99.1%) amid cautious stance on wheels/auto severity; favorable prior-year reserve development added $27.4M to underwriting income, partially offset by $12.0M catastrophe losses .
  • Capital return continues: regular dividend raised to $0.15 in Q1 and further to $0.16 for Q2 2025, marking the 50th consecutive year of increases; book value per share rose 6% from year-end .
  • Near-term stock reaction catalysts: operating EPS beat vs Street, strong property margins, cautious commentary on auto severity and competitive E&S property pricing, and ongoing dividend growth .

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

What Went Well

  • Property and Surety margins drove profitability: Property combined ratio 57.1% (underwriting income $56.9M); Surety combined ratio 68.5% (underwriting income $11.5M) .
  • Investment engine contributed: Net investment income +12% YoY to $36.7M; portfolio total return +1.3% for the quarter .
  • Management confidence in diversified, niche portfolio: “...combined ratio of 82%. A very good start... Our narrow and deep underwriting and claim expertise... allows us to underwrite with discipline...” — CEO Craig Kliethermes .

What Went Wrong

  • Consolidated GAAP revenue declined YoY (-8.4%), primarily due to $42.3M unrealized equity losses; GAAP net EPS fell to $0.68 vs $1.39 in Q1 2024 .
  • Casualty markets pressured: Casualty combined ratio rose to 99.1%; management remains cautious on wheels-based businesses as auto severity persists .
  • Competitive E&S property environment: MGAs and unrated carriers aggressively expanding terms and cutting rates in Florida wind; earthquake rates trending lower as more insureds take risk net .

Financial Results

Sequential Trend (oldest → newest)

MetricQ3 2024Q4 2024Q1 2025
Consolidated Revenue ($USD Billions)$0.470 $0.439 $0.408
Net Premiums Earned ($USD Billions)$0.389 $0.397 $0.398
Net Investment Income ($USD Millions)$36.7 $38.8 $36.7
Underwriting Income ($USD Millions)$40.7 $22.2 $70.5
Combined Ratio (%)89.6 94.4 82.3

Year-over-Year Comparison

MetricQ1 2024Q1 2025
Consolidated Revenue ($USD Billions)$0.445 $0.408
Net Earnings per Share (GAAP) ($)$1.39 $0.68
Operating EPS ($)$0.95 $0.92
Net Premiums Earned ($USD Billions)$0.361 $0.398
Net Investment Income ($USD Millions)$32.8 $36.7
Underwriting Income ($USD Millions)$77.7 $70.5
Combined Ratio (%)78.5 82.3

Consensus vs Actual (Q1 2025)

MetricConsensus EstimateActual
EPS Normalized (Operating) ($)0.8488*$0.92
Revenue ($USD Billions)$0.4420*$0.408
EPS Estimates (#)8*—
Revenue Estimates (#)5*—

Values retrieved from S&P Global.

Segment Breakdown (Q1)

Segment MetricQ1 2024Q1 2025
Casualty – Gross Premiums Written ($USD Millions)$245.3 $278.5
Casualty – Net Premiums Earned ($USD Millions)$198.3 $229.0
Casualty – Underwriting Income ($USD Millions)$13.7 $2.1
Casualty – Combined Ratio (%)93.1 99.1
Property – Gross Premiums Written ($USD Millions)$180.4 $170.1
Property – Net Premiums Earned ($USD Millions)$129.4 $132.5
Property – Underwriting Income ($USD Millions)$57.7 $56.9
Property – Combined Ratio (%)55.4 57.1
Surety – Gross Premiums Written ($USD Millions)$43.0 $42.6
Surety – Net Premiums Earned ($USD Millions)$33.0 $36.8
Surety – Underwriting Income ($USD Millions)$6.3 $11.5
Surety – Combined Ratio (%)80.9 68.5

KPIs

KPIQ3 2024Q4 2024Q1 2025
Operating Cash Flow ($USD Millions)$219.4 $128.1 $103.5
Favorable Prior-Year Reserve Development ($USD Millions)$18.1 $8.7 $27.4
Catastrophe Losses (Net of Reinsurance, $USD Millions)$37.0 (Beryl/Helene) $39.0 (Milton) $12.0 (2025 events)
Investment Portfolio Total Return (%)4.8 -1.1 1.3
Statutory Surplus ($USD Millions)$1,806.7 $1,787.3 $1,787.1

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent GuidanceChange
Regular Dividend per Share ($)Q1 2025 (pay 3/20/25)$0.145 (Q4 2024) $0.15 Raised
Regular Dividend per Share ($)Q2 2025 (pay 6/20/25)$0.15 $0.16 Raised

No formal revenue, margin, OpEx, OI&E, or tax rate guidance was provided in Q1 2025 materials .

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

TopicPrevious (Q3 2024)Previous (Q4 2024)Current (Q1 2025)Trend
Auto Severity (Casualty)Not emphasized; hurricane focus Caution on wheels; hurricane impacts Persistent severity; 17% auto rate; reserve strengthening; selective underwriting Deteriorating
E&S Property CompetitionRebuilding after storm capacity loss Milton hurricane; capacity tight MGAs and unrated carriers aggressive in FL wind; earthquake rates down Competitive pressure rising
Earthquake MarketLimited mention Limited mention Insureds going net; primary rates down; reinsurance cost modestly lower Softer pricing
Tariffs/MacroHurricanes drove activity Special dividend; macro not central Tariff uncertainty; potential recession playbook; impacts on construction bids and transport volumes Elevated uncertainty
Hawaii HomeownersWildfire recovery context —Growth with +18% rates; some re-entry by competitors Improving opportunity
Investment Yields+15% NII; strong fixed-income marks -1.1% qtr total return; capital returned Purchases at ~5.1% avg yield; +1.3% total return Stable carry

Management Commentary

  • Strategic posture: “We began our 61st year…with a combined ratio of 82%. Our narrow and deep underwriting and claim expertise…allows us to underwrite with discipline…” — Craig Kliethermes, CEO .
  • Property drivers: “$17.6M of favorable prior years’ reserve development…Storm losses totaled $12M…Property had a great start…57 combined ratio.” — Todd Bryant, CFO .
  • Casualty actions: “Auto liability…achieved a 17% rate increase…raised required underlying limits…slowed growth in problematic areas.” — Jenni Klobnak, COO .
  • Competitive landscape: “MGAs…aggressive in the Florida wind market…slashing rates.” — Jenni Klobnak . “Lack of discipline is disheartening…same market doing dumb things right now.” — Craig Kliethermes .
  • Investment framework: “Fixed income purchases averaged 5.1%…book value per share increased 6% from year-end.” — Todd Bryant .

Q&A Highlights

  • Tariff and recession playbook: Diversified portfolio mitigates exposure; construction and transport volumes could slow, partially offset by premium uplift from higher valuations; long-term neutral view, near-term uncertainty .
  • Auto severity and transportation: Continued rate and underwriting actions; reserve strengthening in wheels; selective non-renewals and pricing discipline; loss control engagement on-site .
  • Earthquake market and reinsurance: Primary rates down as insureds retain risk; quake within cat treaty; modest reduction in cost tied to lower exposure .
  • E&S property competition: MGAs/unrated carriers/Lloyd’s aggressively expanding capacity; expectation that undisciplined markets could later retrench, benefiting disciplined carriers .
  • Small commercial opportunities: Focus on professional-led packages and small contractors; careful on auto coverages; rate increases and coverage limits applied .

Estimates Context

  • EPS Normalized (Operating) beat: $0.92 actual vs $0.85* consensus; strength driven by Property and Surety underwriting and 12% NII growth; reserve releases added $27.4M (offset by $12.0M cats). Bold beat: EPS Normalized beat by ~8% . Values retrieved from S&P Global.
  • Revenue miss: $0.408B actual vs $0.442B* consensus; GAAP revenue impacted by $(42.3)M unrealized equity losses vs $45.3M gains in Q1 2024, compressing consolidated revenue. Bold miss: Revenue missed by ~7.8% . Values retrieved from S&P Global.
  • Potential estimate revisions: Expect upward bias to operating EPS trajectories in Property/Surety, offset by cautious assumptions for Casualty (auto severity, higher underlying loss ratios) and competitive E&S property pricing .

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Underwriting remains resilient: Combined ratio 82.3% with Property/Surety strength; maintain confidence in underwriting discipline and reserve prudence .
  • Mind the GAAP optics: Equity market marks can swing consolidated revenue/GAAP EPS; operating earnings better reflect core performance this quarter .
  • Casualty caution persists: Wheels/auto severity necessitate higher rates and stricter underwriting; expect tempered favorable reserve development vs prior year .
  • E&S property cycle turning competitive: MGAs/unrated capacity pressuring rates/terms; RLI leaning into best accounts while preserving margin discipline .
  • Dividend growth as a signal: 50th consecutive year of increases; Q1 raised to $0.15; Q2 to $0.16—ongoing capital-return support to total shareholder return .
  • Investment income tailwind: New money yields (~5.1%) above book yield; portfolio total return positive despite equity volatility—supports earnings carry .
  • Watch catalysts: Operating EPS beats, property margin durability, auto severity trajectory, and potential tariff-related macro impacts on construction/transport volumes .